Sanctioning Committee statement on the WRTC 2022 (Bologna, July 2023) results
Following publication of the WRTC 2026 Judging Committee report on 1 September 2026, the WRTC 2022 Organising Committee referred the 2023 results to the WRTC Sanctioning Committee (SC). The SC formed a working group to examine the 2023 logs using the methods described in the 2026 report. The SC has accepted the working group's findings and has decided as follows.
The 2023 scheme
Appendix 5 of the 2026 report describes what was found in 2023: the winning team's 20-metre starting frequency was held for the final hour before the start by a callsign that submitted no log, appears in no other log, and was never heard again. There was also a group of callsigns from rare entities, none of which submitted a log or appear elsewhere in the 5,589 logs submitted for the 2023 IARU contest, delivered multiplier contacts to WRTC teams.
The 2026 report identified 22 callsigns that were believed to be fraudulent.
From Appendix 5 of the 2026 report:
"I44W's 20-meter starting frequency was held and transferred in the same manner as shown in the examples in Appendix 2. YQ5W appeared at 11:01z, settled on 14001.8 kHz, and called CQ there continuously through the final hour before the start, last spotted at 11:59:52z. I44W's first logged contact of the contest is in the 12:00z minute on that frequency, where it then ran. YQ5W submitted no log, is not listed as an operator in any of the 5,589 logs submitted for that contest, appears in no other station's log, and was never spotted again. I44W's operators were VE3DZ and UW7LL. I44W was the declared winner of the 2023 event."
"The following are now believed to be multipliers fraudulently injected into logs at WRTC-2023 in the same manner as occurred in WRTC-2026: 4J3DJ, 4K6OF, 4L4DX, 9H1XT, 9K2MU, A41JZ, A61ZX, A65DR, BX4AG, CO2SG, EK3GM, ER0FEO, EX8MJ, FM5FE, HZ1BH, OA4EA, OD5PY, SV9CJO, TK5CH (and its miscopy TK5CS), YV5EN, ZP5DPA — plus YB8RVI and ZA1AK, genuine entrants whose callsigns were pirated. The pirated QSOs are refuted by the owners’ own submitted logs. The 22 callsigns produced an average of 9.3 QSOs for each of the 58 WRTC-2023 stations — 540 in all. Of those, 53 went to the I44W (VE3DZ & UW7LL) team, with most resulting in a multiplier."
The SC working group examined every contact with those callsigns in all 58 team logs. They made 540 contacts with WRTC teams, an average of nine per team. Two teams stand apart. I44W (UW7LL, VE3DZ) received 46 of them, worth 37 multipliers. I43Z (RW7K, RA9P) received 27, worth 25 multipliers. The next team received 19. The callsigns also divide cleanly into two groups: sixteen all worked I44W, and the other seven never worked I44W, and all worked I43Z. The pattern is the same one the 2026 Judging Committee found for MB2M and MB2A, and it can be verified from the public logs.
The removal list in Appendix 5 of the 2026 Judging Committee report the 21 callsigns named there plus the TK5CS miscopy, 22 in all. Every contact any team made with those callsigns is removed as a pirate contact, with no penalty, at rule 7 points (CW 2/5, SSB 3/6).
YB8RVI and ZA1AK, the two genuine entrants named in Appendix 5 whose callsigns were pirated, are not removed again. Their pirated contacts are refuted by the owners' own logs and were already scored as not-in-log in 2023, so they are already out of the official numbers.
A DXCC multiplier is removed only where the team had no other credited contact with that entity on that band. HQ stations do not preserve a DXCC multiplier (rule 8.2).
The 2023 cheerleading deductions are kept as set by the 2023 JC.
The rules
The WRTC 2022 competition rules are, in the relevant clauses, word for word the same as the 2026 rules. Rule 12.2 prohibits a team from revealing its identity in any way and states that doing so may result in immediate disqualification. Rule 12.7 permits disqualification for taking credit for excessive unverifiable QSOs or unverifiable multipliers.
Decision
I44W (UW7LL, VE3DZ) is disqualified under Rule 12.2 for the arranged transfer of its starting frequency, which required the team’s identity and starting frequency to be known in advance, and under Rule 12.7 for the multipliers it took credit for from the callsigns above.
I43Z (RW7K, RA9P) is disqualified under Rule 12.7 for the multipliers it took credit for from the callsigns above. Twenty-five multipliers from a group of callsigns that served this team is excessive within the meaning of the rule.
As in 2026, the disqualifications apply to the teams, not to individual operators. The SC makes no finding about who operated the callsigns in question.
The revised results are:
The full table is attached. These results replace the results announced in July 2023.
The SC congratulates DJ5MW and DL1IAO as champions of WRTC 2022, and 9A7DX/9A3LG and F8DBF/F1AKK as second and third.
The 2023 Judging Committee adjudicated the logs with the tools and time available to it and could not have seen this pattern. It became visible only when the 2026 Judging Committee developed methods to find the same scheme in 2026 and then applied them to the 2023 logs.
Tine Brajnik, S50A
Chairman WRTC Sanctioning Committee